Immigration, as the great Israeli military historian Martin van Creveld has shown, is war. And that war, not WWI, WWII, or the Cold War, was the true existential war that America faced, and lost, as demonstrated by this selection from The Old World in the New: The Significance of Past and Present Immigration to the American People, published in 1914 by sociologist E.A. Ross:
If
you should ask an Englishman whether the tone of political life in his country
would remain unaffected by the admission to the electorate of a couple of
million Cypriotes, Vlachs, and Bessarabians after five years’ residence, he
would take you for a madman. Suggest to the German that the plane of political
intelligence in reading and thinking Germany would not be lowered by the access
to the ballot-box of multitudes of Serbs, Georgians, and Druses of Lebanon, and
he will consign you to bedlam. Assure the son of Norway that the vote of the
Persian or Yemenite, of sixty months’ residence in Norway, will be as often
wise and right as his own, and he will be insulted. It is only we Americans who
assume that the voting of the Middle Atlantic States, with their million of
naturalized citizens, or of the East North Central States, with their million,
is as sane, discriminating, and forward-looking as it would be without them.
The Italian historian and
sociologist Ferrero, after reviewing our immigration policy, concludes that the
Americans, far from being “practical,” are really the mystics of the modern
world. He says: “To confer citizenship each year upon great numbers of men born
and educated in foreign countries—men who come with ideas and sympathies
totally out of spirit with the diverse conditions in the new country; to grant
them political rights they do not want, and of which they have never thought;
to compel them to declare allegiance to a political constitution which they
often do not understand; to try to transform subjects of old European
monarchies into free citizens of young American republics over night—is not all
this to do violence to common sense?”
As I sought to show, near the end of
my initial chapter, the conditions of settlement of this country caused those
of uncommon energy and venturesomeness to outmultiply the rest of the
population. Thus came into existence the pioneering breed; and this breed
increased until it is safe to estimate that fully half of white Americans with
native grandparents have one or more pioneers among their ancestors. Whatever
valuable race traits distinguish the American people from the parent European
stocks are due to the efflorescence of this breed. Without it there would have
been little in the performance of our people to arrest the attention of the
world. Now we confront the melancholy spectacle of this pioneer breed being
swamped and submerged by an overwhelming tide of latecomers from the old-world
hive. In Atlanta still seven out of eight white men had American parents; in
Nashville and Richmond, four out of five; in Kansas City, two out of three; and
in Los Angeles, one out of two; but in Detroit, Cleveland, and Paterson one man
out of five had American parents; in Chicago and New York, one out of six; in
Milwaukee, one out of seven; and in Fall River, one out of nine. Certainly
never since the colonial era have the foreign-born and their children formed so
large a proportion of the American people as at the present moment. I scanned
368 persons as they passed me in Union Square, New York, at a time when the
garment-workers of the Fifth Avenue lofts were returning to their homes. Only
thirty-eight of these passers-by had the type of face one would find at a
county fair in the West or South.
In the six or seven hundred thousand
strangers that yearly join themselves to us for good and all, there are to be
found, of course, every talent and every beauty. Out of the steerage come
persons as fine and noble as any who have trodden American soil. Any adverse
characterization of an immigrant stream implies, then, only that the trait is
relatively frequent, not that it is universal.
In this sense it is fair to say that
the blood now being injected into the veins of our people is “sub-common.” To
one accustomed to the aspect of the normal American population, the Caliban
type shows up with a frequency that is startling. Observe immigrants not as
they come travel-wan up the gang-plank, nor as they issue toil-begrimed from
pit’s mouth or mill gate, but in their gatherings, washed, combed, and in their
Sunday best. You are struck by the fact that from ten to twenty per cent. are
hirsute, low-browed, big-faced persons of obviously low mentality. Not that
they suggest evil. They simply look out of place in black clothes and stiff collar,
since clearly they belong in skins, in wattled huts at the close of the Great
Ice Age. These oxlike men are descendants of those who always stayed
behind. Those in whom the soul burns with the dull, smoky flame of the
pine-knot stuck to the soil, and are now thick in the sluiceways of
immigration. Those in whom it burns with a clear, luminous flame have been
attracted to the cities of the home land and, having prospects, have no motive
to submit themselves to the hardships of the steerage.
To the practised eye, the
physiognomy of certain groups unmistakably proclaims inferiority of type. I
have seen gatherings of the foreign-born in which narrow and sloping foreheads
were the rule. The shortness and smallness of the crania were very noticeable.
There was much facial asymmetry. Among the women, beauty, aside from the
fleeting, epidermal bloom of girlhood, was quite lacking. In every face there
was something wrong—lips thick, mouth coarse, upper lip too long, cheek-bones
too high, chin poorly formed, the bridge of the nose hollowed, the base of the
nose tilted, or else the whole face prognathous. There were so many sugar-loaf
heads, moon-faces, slit mouths, lantern-jaws, and goose-bill noses that one
might imagine a malicious jinn had amused himself by casting human beings in a
set of skew-molds discarded by the Creator.
Our captains of industry give a
crowbar to the immigrant with a number nine face on a number six head, make a
dividend out of him, and imagine that is the end of the matter. They overlook that
this man will beget children in his image—two or three times as many as the
American—and that these children will in turn beget children. They chuckle at
having opened an inexhaustible store of cheap tools and, lo! the American
people is being altered for all time by these tools. Once before, captains of
industry took a hand in making this people. Colonial planters imported Africans
to hoe in the sun, to “develop” the tobacco, indigo, and rice plantations.
Then, as now, business-minded men met with contempt the protests of a few
idealists against their way of “building up the country.”
Those
promoters of prosperity are dust, but they bequeathed a situation which in four
years wiped out more wealth than two hundred years of slavery had built up, and
which presents to-day the one unsolvable problem in this country. Without
likening immigrants to negroes, one may point out how the latter-day employer
resembles the old-time planter in his blindness to the effects of his labor
policy upon the blood of the nation.
If America is to leave behind any historical legacy for the ages, it
is this. First, pick your own damn cotton. Second, always sink the ships.
Third, never let business-minded men set national policy, because for all their
pragmatism, they are totally incapable of seeing anything beyond tomorrow's
pocketbook.
Seldom has a Cassandra foreseen coming catastrophe more clearly.
It is small, though rather cold, comfort to know that the die was cast long
before most of us were even born. Even so, Ross's closing paragraph is a
haunting one.
“The Roman world was
laughing when it died.” Any couple or any people that does not feel it has
anything to transmit to its children may well reason in such fashion. A couple
may reflect, “It is simpler, speedier, and cheaper for us to adopt orphans than
to produce children of our own.” A nation may reason, “Why burden ourselves
with the rearing of children? Let them perish unborn in the womb of time. The
immigrants will keep up the population.” A people that has no more respect for
its ancestors and no more pride of race than this deserves the extinction that
surely awaits it.
http://voxday.blogspot.com/2020/10/the-war-that-was-lost.html