Labels

Thursday, November 5, 2020

Michigan USPS Whistleblower Claims Late Ballots Received Backdated Postmarks | Zero Hedge

Update 0958ET: The USPS Inspector General's office has contacted Project Veritas following their report from a postal employee who says he was instructed to collect ballots after the election cutoff so they could be backdated.

"They're aware of this, it falls under their jurisdiction, they're assessing whether to investigate," said James O'Keefe, founder of PV.

*  *  *

A US Postal Service employee from Michigan has reportedly turned whistleblower, telling Project Veritas that his supervisor instructed mail carriers to collect and segregate new ballot envelopes received after the election cutoff so that they could be fraudulently back-dated with a Nov. 3 postmark.

Poll workers count absentee ballots for the city of Detroit

Whistleblower: "We were told to collect any ballots that we find in mailboxes, collection boxes, et cetera, for outgoing mail, at the end of the day, we are supposed to separate them from the standard letter mail, so they can hand-stamp them with yesterday’s date—and put them through the Express Mail system—to get wherever they need to go," said the whistleblower, adding "For clarification, today is the fourth of November."

James O'Keefe: "Hand-stamp them with Nov. 3’s date?"

Whistleblower: "Yes

James O'Keefe: "That seems wrong--"

Whistleblower: "Yeah, that’s why I am coming forward with this information. That is a very shady—in addition to, as far as I am aware, we’re not supposed to be counting ballots that are postmarked after the third of November here in the state of Michigan."

The Insider said he was shocked when Barlow Branch morning supervisor Jonathan Clarke told a group of mail carriers how late ballots would be handled.

...

The Insider said there was a process set up for the post office workers involved in the bogus postmark scheme. -Project Veritas

https://www.zerohedge.com/political/michigan-usps-whistleblower-claims-late-ballots-backdated 

Game-On for the Coup? - By Michael Anton

It will all go according to plan—unless we stop it.

Strictly speaking, a coup is an illegitimate change of government by violent means. But what if you can do it without violence? To win without fighting is best, Sun Tzu says. An ostensibly (“mostly”) peaceful ouster from power is preferable to the use of force because it can much more easily be sold as “our democracy” at work.

 

National polls consistently predicted a huge Biden blowout. That they were wrong (again) is demonstrated by the facts that (a) the 2020 popular vote is, so far (California is not fully counted), a mere two-point spread, hardly a blowout; (b) Trump got a higher share of the vote than last time; and (C) Trump received far more total votes than last time.

 

But it’s the swing states that matter. Here (again) Trump was supposed to lose—if not necessarily bigly in every case, at least widely.

 

But throughout the day, the president consistently outperformed the polls. He crushed his 2016 performance in Florida. He also outperformed in Iowa, Ohio, South Carolina, and Texas. Senators he was supposed to drag down with him, including Joni Ernst, Lindsey Graham, and Mitch McConnell, won handily. Even Susan Collins, who was supposed to be sure goner and lose by at least three, won by nine. A party that was “certain” to lose the Senate has kept it and gained (so far) six seats in the House.

 

Looking at states no one expected Trump to lose, his overperformance is even more stark. The polling average for West Virginia was Trump +17; he won it by 39. Kansas was estimated at +9; the result was +15.

 

Throughout the day the president was also outperforming his expected result in key states such as Arizona, Georgia, Michigan, Minnesota, Nevada, North Carolina, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin. He even, for a time, looked like he was within striking distance in Virginia, a state Hillary Clinton won by five points in 2016. At one point the New York Times’s “meter” had Trump’s chances in North Carolina at 92%. The needle was also sliding in the president’s direction in Arizona and Georgia, among others.

 

And then, suddenly, the counting stopped in at least five states (or parts of states): Georgia, Michigan, Nevada, North Carolina, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin; all but one with a Democratic governor (coincidence, surely!). When has that ever happened? Well, it happened in Broward County, Florida, in 2018, when a dodgy Democratic election official appeared to be intervening, illicitly, on her party’s behalf. The process only got back underway when the state’s (Republican) governor intervened and had her removed from the process.

 

But getting back to last night, some time in the wee hours, additional ballots were “found” and added to early totals which had Trump ahead. To no one’s surprise, those votes were overwhelmingly—literally as much as 100% in some batches—for Biden. According to Nate Silver, no one’s idea of a Trumpist, one tranche of 23,277 votes that turned up in Philadelphia were “all for Biden.” Absent some kind of harvesting or fraud (or both), that’s a logical and statistical impossibility.

 

Through the night, all such ballots came from heavily Democratic areas posting unusually, improbably high turnout. 85% in Milwaukee? A city that turned out at only 61% in 2016, and even with Obama on the ballot in 2012, at 71%? But 85% for Sleepy Joe? According to one report, seven Milwaukee precincts returned more presidential votes than they have registered voters. Turnout in Wisconsin overall is alleged to have been 89.25%, more than five standard deviations for the state’s mean turnout since 1960—another statistical impossibility.

 

One might also wonder why this urban Blue wave materialized only in close states. Milwaukee was way up but not Cleveland? Philly but not St. Louis? Granted Ohio and Missouri are Red, but their big cities aren’t.

 

How It’s Done

 

We’ve seen this movie before. This is how they beat Scott Walker in Wisconsin in 2018, Tom Foley in Connecticut in 2010, and Norm Coleman in Minnesota in 2008.

 

Why stop the count? Because that’s the only way to know how many votes you need to “win.” Sure, you can just brute force things by backing up a truck full of ballots. But that looks bad. You might even end up counting more votes than there are registered voters in the state. Better to eke out a narrow win. As Joseph Kennedy, Sr. allegedly said to his second son, “I’m not paying for a landslide.”

 

Speaking of the Kennedys, veteran political observer Theodore H. White—in their company on election night 1960—explained how it’s done. In Illinois, the race came down to

downstate (Republican) versus Cook County (Democratic), and the bosses, holding back totals from key precincts, were playing out their concealed cards under pressure of publicity as in a giant game of blackjack….

 

The AP ticker chattered its keys once more and reported: “With all downstate precincts now reported in, and only Cook County precincts unreported, Richard Nixon has surged into the lead by 3,000 votes.”

 

I was dismayed, for if Nixon really carried Illinois, the game was all but over. And at this point I was jabbed from dismay by the outburst of jubilation from young Dick Donahue, who yelped, “He’s got them! Daley made them go first! He’s still holding back—watch him play his hand now.” I was baffled, they were elated. But they knew the counting game better than I, and as if in response to Donahue’s yelp, the ticker, having stuttered along for several minutes with other results, announced: “With the last precincts of Cook County now in, Senator Kennedy has won a lead of 8,000 votes to carry Illinois’s 27 electoral votes.”

 

Later that evening, Kennedy told his friend Ben Bradlee of an early call from Daley, when all seemed in doubt. “With a little bit of luck and the help of a few close friends,” Daley had assured Kennedy before the AP had pushed out the count, “you’re going to carry Illinois.”

Is that what happened last night? Sure looks like it. Plus ça change.

 

To say nothing of other considerations, it’s hard to believe that an eight-point win in Ohio would be coupled with losses throughout the rest of the upper Midwest, or that historically deep purple Florida would go strongly for Trump while Georgia and North Carolina would not. Are those states really so unrepresentative of the American electorate?

 

Stop the Steal

 

The thing could (but will never) be proved. Those who ran the operation are also in charge of all the potential investigating agencies. There’s zero chance they will use any of that power to uncover their own malfeasance. Think a Biden Justice Department will look into it?

 

Expect instead a media typhoon of propaganda insisting that the results are all legit, that any anomaly you think you see (or saw) is a “conspiracy theory,” or at any rate innocently explainable by mundane process details too boring to get into. Twitter is already slapping warnings on the accounts of those who point out irregularities. How long before they start outright suspensions?

 

Will it work? That depends on the president and his allies and what they do. The odds and the forces arrayed against them are immense.

 

What would I have them do? I’m no expert but the crew at Revolver has some good ideas: (1) challenge the late-night “finds” in the courts; (2) hold rallies in contested states; (3) urge GOP officials in close states to expose shenanigans and, if necessary, to refuse to seat Biden electors in the event of a fake count; (4) mount a campaign to marshal grassroots public opinion in the president’s favor. Convince the people that if in fact the election is in the process of being stolen, the president and his allies are going to fight the steal on their behalf. If middle America wants to prevent this election from being stolen, it will have to be willing to act—now. I know they are willing, but they need to hear from the President and his best surrogates. I’d get Trump on Tucker, tonight, to explain his plan.

 

But in another sense, the Democrats’ plan won’t “work.” Even if the steal can be made to stick, half the country won’t accept it. That is, they’ll accept the reality that power is now in the hands of a party that took it by fraud. But they won’t believe that the election was fair or the outcome real. They will believe, or be confirmed in a belief that’s been brewing for a long time, that the system is rigged, the process is fake, the ruling class are liars, the government is illegitimate, and that they themselves are subjects and not citizens—anything but a free people with a say over its own destiny. If the ruling class can get away with this, they will be able to get away with anything. And they will know it.

 

The irony will be that those who, over the last four years, have bleated the loudest about “our democracy” will have been most responsible for killing it off.

Michael Anton is a lecturer at Hillsdale College.

https://americanmind.org/post/game-on-for-the-coup/

Tuesday, November 3, 2020

If you are not watching DaTrumpslide here - you are missing all the fun - regularly updated! - CL

 Early county review

CURRENT VERDICT: early returns look VERY solidly pro-Trump. It's all but over already.

Quote of the Day: You're not going to learn anything useful about the election outcome on here until 7pm, i.e. when they start counting votes. - Nate Silver, 538


Broward County (M=67)

2016:

  • 1,179,189 registered
  • 822,837 cast
  • 71.8 percent turnout
2020:
  • 1,267,187 registered (+7.5%)
  • 471,474 mail ballots received
Reports: 
  • Biden running 1.2 percent behind Hillary so far.
  • FL all voting: Rs +56,009. Broward, election day only: Ds up 2300, Palm Beach, election day only: Rs +12,000 (!)
  • Trump seriously overperforming in Miami-Dade, up 4.4 percent vs 2016. FL r/d: Rs +92,692 Rs +14,000 in  . . . PALM BEACH on election day.
  • There are only four blue counties on election day. One is D by only 14 votes, one by 48 votes, one by  1070 votes, and Broward by 3,294. We are 4,426 votes from having every FL county red today.
  • At noon, Trump ALREADY has more votes in Broward County than he did in 2016: 204,368 to 193,658. 
  • As of 1 PM, more votes had been cast in FL than were cast in 2016, 9,967,361 to 9,420,039. Donald Trump currently has an estimated lead of 116,422 which exceeds his 2016 winning margin of 113,000.
  • "Starting to fall down the Florida election day turnout rabbit hole. Already went for a run so I think I'd just better go and play some FIFA or something." - Nate Silver
  • "Voter enthusiasm has been very underwhelming here in Broward County. Turnout looked low on the second to last day of early voting when I went."

Mecklenburg County (M=64)

Reports:

  • Trump picked up 3.05% in early votes vis-a-vis 2016.
Philadelphia County (M=83)

Wayne County (M=67)

Hennepin County (M=62)

Milwaukee County (M=67)

Politics as Power and Intimidation • by Gary DeMar • The American Vision

As citizens, we carry a burning responsibility. It means when we elect men to public office we cannot do it as lightly as we flip a coin. It means that after we’ve elected them, we can’t sit back and say “Our job is done. What they do now doesn’t concern us.” That philosophy of indifference is what the enemies of decent government want. If we allow them to have their way and grow strong and vicious, then the heroic struggle which welded thousands of lovely towns like this into a great nation means nothing. Then we are not citizens ... We’re traitors.

Most of us have heard of Mr. Smith Goes to Washington (1939), about a naïve Senator who ends up taking on the political establishment. It’s a reminder that there’s nothing new under the political sun. It stars Jimmy Stewart and Jean Arthur and was directed by Frank Capra who also directed Stewart in It’s a Wonderful Life.

It’s one of AMC’s Top 100 films.

It was not popular with the political establishment crowd when it first came out:

The wonderfully-acted, absorbing and human film was popular at the box-office and critically successful too. However, the film caused some controversy and pressure was brought to bear to hinder its release (two months after the outbreak of WWII in Europe), due to the fact that Capra’s film was propagandistic, depicted political corruption, and appeared to paint an anti-democratic picture of the US government and its inner workings. But the film also called for faith in traditional American values of patriotism and faith in the people, and provided an educational lesson in how bills are passed through Congress. (MoxieCinema)

A little-known film, not as well acted as Mr. Smith Goes to Washington, and with no major stars in the league with Jimmy Stewart, Jean Arthur, and Claude Rains, but loaded with a stable of often seen character actors, is the 1943 A Stranger in Town that stars Frank Morgan. Morgan played the Wizard in The Wizard of Oz (1939).

The closing courtroom scene is a great summary of why political participation is so important because it sums up the significance of citizenship, electoral participation, and overturning of political corruption.

Using Film to Teach Christianity

Using Classic Films to Teach the Christian Worldview

Movies are a self-contained world. The writers and producers make the rules and the circumstances for the worlds they create. Most often though, films use the assumed order of the natural world and don't attempt to re-write reality for the viewer. Films either reinforce the real world or they rebel against it. Either way, they provide a great way to think through worldview issues and their consequences. 

Buy Now

Morgan is Supreme Court Justice John Josephus Grant who finishes with the final case of the year and heads off for a hunting vacation in the out-of-the-way town of Crown Port.

There he sees political corruption first hand. Hiding his identity, he assists an inexperienced lawyer who’s running for mayor but is ground into political dust by the political machine operated by the mayor, a band of violent henchmen, and an intimidated bought-off judge. Sound familiar?

Violent henchmen are operating and tolerated by corrupt mayors and attorneys general today in some of our nation’s major Democrat-controlled cities. “Far-left agitators call for death of ‘Nazi’ cops, scream at NYPD: 'Hope all of your children get raped and killed.’” (Source) There’s this from radical leftist organization Choose Democracy:

We need an unprecedented number of Americans to take to the streets and stay in the streets until he [Trump] concedes. But protest won’t be enough. What we’re talking about is a coup. We need an unprecedented number of Americans to take to the streets and stay in the streets until he concedes. But protest won’t be enough.

Businesses in Democrat-run cities are boarding up their store fronts because they fear a leftist-Democrat backlash if Biden loses or the outcome is contested by Pres. Trump if the media and Nancy Pelosi declare Biden the winner.

Not to be outdone, there's this:

Dozens of leaked internal documents and Zoom call video footage were made public Sunday describing plans by progressive activists and federal workers to disrupt and destabilize the outcome of Tuesday's presidential election, including plans to "shut down the White House." (WND)

A Stranger in Town is a microcosm of today’s political corruption writ ever larger.

Restoring the Foundation of Civilization

Restoring the Foundation of Civilization

There are many Christians who will not participate in civilization-building efforts that include economics, journalism, politics, education, and science because they believe (or have been taught to believe) these areas of thought are outside the realm of what constitutes a Christian worldview.

Nothing could be further from the truth.

 

Buy Now

Through some legal maneuvering, Grant and his young legal protégé swear out arrest warrants for the mayor and his enforcement thugs. But it’s the short speech during a hearing to expose the corruption of the mayor that Judge Grant gives that makes watching A Stranger in Town worthwhile. Today’s mayors, governors, judges, congressmen, presidents, Supreme Court justices, and especially voters could learn a few lessons from it:

Mr. Connison, you have asked by what right I have interfered in this situation. You still want an answer? ... It’s only right that you should know why I, a stranger, have become involved in your affairs. Believe me, it’s not because I am a justice of the Supreme Court. It’s because, like all of you here, I’m a citizen of this country. That is no little honor. Men have fought revolutions and died to be called citizen.

As citizens, we carry a burning responsibility. It means when we elect men to public office we cannot do it as lightly as we flip a coin. It means that after we’ve elected them, we can’t sit back and say “Our job is done. What they do now doesn’t concern us.” That philosophy of indifference is what the enemies of decent government want. If we allow them to have their way and grow strong and vicious, then the heroic struggle which welded thousands of lovely towns like this into a great nation means nothing. Then we are not citizens ... We’re traitors.

The great liberties by which we live have been bought with blood. The kind of government we get is the kind of government we want. Government “of the people, by the people, and for the people” can mean any kind of government. It’s our duty to make it mean only one kind ... Uncorrupted, free, united. I believe, Mayor Connison, I believe I’ve answered your question.

 You can watch the full film here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?app=desktop&v=B_n-Z5fiXvo

https://americanvision.org/24922/politics-as-power-and-intimidation/

Monday, November 2, 2020

The Messianic and Destructive Character of American Education • by Gary DeMar • The American Vision (Whoever controls the schools rules the world.)

The State feeds on people. It needs people to function, to survive. The money the State spends to propagandize children comes from the people the State ultimately wants to control. Judges, teachers, politicians, and journalists have mostly been educated by the State. Why are we surprised when they support the State?

Whoever controls the schools rules the world.

Kevin DeYoung is the senior pastor of Christ Covenant Church in Matthews, North Carolina. Recently, he wrote a comprehensive review of Rousas J. Rushdoony’s little book Law and Liberty. DeYoung describes what is commendable about the book and what he considerers “Bridges Too Far.”

DeYoung is correct when he writes the following:

Throughout 32 chapters, Rushdoony makes a principled case for a limited government of just laws, what he calls on occasion Christian Libertarianism. He defends capital punishment (9–14). He emphasizes the importance of private property as a bulwark against tyranny (83). He denounces all utopian schemes, dreamed up by Marxists and Communists, which envision political machinations ushering in a world free from disease, poverty, crime, war, prejudice, and ignorance (5). He laments the growing expectation found in the American people that government will be our savior (77). He fears we are trading our God-given liberties for promises of security (78).

What he gets wrong is that he refuses to acknowledge how our nation has gotten to this place in history. He fails to identify the source of why many people today embrace the worldview that has split our nation in half.

The Children of Caesar

Dr. Voddie Baucham persuasively argues that Christian parents need to take the initiative in their children's education and stop turning them over to the anti-God environment of the government school system. Using Scripture, statistics, and sound reasoning, Dr. Baucham powerfully makes the case that whoever controls the schools does indeed control the world.

Buy Now

In my estimation, what DeYoung mostly objects to are the things that make Law and Liberty essential reading for Christians, especially on the topic of public education. Keep in mind that Law and Liberty was never designed to be a scholarly analysis of what ails our nation. Rushdoony draws from his vast and diverse readings over decades.

I found this comment by DeYoung off base:

Rushdoony presents his arguments with an air of great learning and erudition, but, at least in this volume, there’s little sense that he has read serious and relevant academic work in the areas he’s addressing. He makes almost no effort, for example, to support his historical claims. 

DeYoung writes this after stating that the short chapters were “originally delivered as a series of radio addresses in 1966 and 1967.” Anyone familiar with Rushdoony’s works knows that he read widely. Scripts written for radio generally are not filled with relevant footnotes and scholarly arguments requiring detailed analysis. Take a look at J. Gresham Machen’s Christianity and Liberalism where there are few footnotes and C.S. Lewis’ The Case for Christianity that were originally “broadcast talks.” These and other essays by Lewis were compiled and became Mere Christianity. There is not a single footnote.

Rushdoony showed his scholarly erudition in his massive The Institutes of Biblical Law, The Messianic Character of American Education (1963) describing the educational philosophies in the United States beginning with Horace Mann, The One and the Many, and Politics of Guilt and Pity.

Horace Mann | National Portrait Gallery
Horace Mann (1796–1859)

For several years Rushdoony was often called as an expert witness in homeschooling court cases. In 1987, he testified in the Leeper v. Arlington case in Texas. “The plaintiffs were homeschooling families; the defendant, the public school establishment of Texas. The attorney who pled the case for the homeschoolers was Shelby Sharpe.” Here’s what Sharpe said about Rushdoony’s testimony:

His testimony was way beyond anything I’d hoped for. It was one of the few times in my career that I ever saw a witness destroy the attorney who was trying to examine him. (Source)

You can read the Rushdoony Leeper v. Arlington transcript of the Texas homeschool trial here.

Dr. Gary North had this to say about Rushdoony’s Messianic Character of American Education:

The philosophy of the statists who designed America’s public schools was messianic. R. J. Rushdoony’s 1963 book, The Messianic Character of American Education, goes through the primary sources of three dozen of these social experimenters. The footnotes are detailed. These men were open about what they were attempting to do: reform the American people and American society through tax-funded education. They disagreed with each other on the proper pedagogical methods, but they were unified in their agreement that the state, not parents, should be in charge of the education of all children. The state would then become the redeeming agent of society. It would replace churches and families as agents of redemption.

This brings me back to Keven DeYoung’s review of Rushdoony’s Law and Liberty. It seems that DeYoung’s review is most critical of Rushdoony’s views on public education. He claims that Rushdoony “has failed to describe his opponents in ways they would recognize. Rushdoony fails that test when it comes to describing public education.”

Whoever Controls the Schools Rules the World

"One of the most useful tools in the quest for power is the educational system." It's been said that "the philosophy of the classroom in this generation will be the philosophy of life in the next generation." Whoever Controls the Schools Rules the World shows how government controlled education is being used as a vehicle for social change. Our worldview opponents understand that education is where the war of ideas is fought. If Christians are serious about securing the future for our children, they must understand the nature of the war we are fighting. 

 

Buy Now

If DeYoung had read Messianic Character of American Education, he would have known that Rushdoony described his opponents accurately since he, as Gary North writes, “went through the primary source documents relating to the two dozen founders of American progressive education,” and this was before the internet. “The Messianic Character of American Education was the first academic treatise to provide a detailed look at the theology of America's only established church. No subsequent treatise has matched it for both conciseness and its comprehensiveness. To understand the confessional war we are in, begin here.”

DeYoung references four examples from Law and Liberty on the topic of education that he takes issue with:

  • “Instead of rebirth by Jesus Christ, they offer rebirth by means of a statist, progressivist curriculum. The public schools are the creatures of the state, and therefore they teach and exalt the authority of the democratic state” (43).
  • “State controlled schools have replaced religion with magic, and the goal of education today is the same as that of ancient magicians, the total control of all reality by man” (72).
  • Education today is not concerned with knowledge, but with techniques of power (167).
  • “State supported education is totalitarian education. The essence of totalitarianism is simply this, that it maintains that the state has all the answers to life, and virtually every sphere of human activity should be governed by the state.... Common to all forms of totalitarianism is a belief in the state control of education” (178).

These comments are part of Law and Liberty’s strength. They are spot on. Although written in the 1960s, they describe exactly what has taken place with public (government) education. Of course, not all teachers who are teaching in government schools would agree with Rushdoony’s assessment that they are teaching a thoroughly secular curriculum, but those who design the course material and outline public education’s ultimate goals would.

Some would even admit it, as atheist and secular humanist John Dunphy did:

I am convinced that the battle for humankind's future must be waged and won in the public school classroom by teachers who correctly perceive their role as the proselytizers of a new faith: a religion of humanity that recognizes and respects the spark of what theologians call divinity in every human being. These teachers must embody the same selfless dedication as the most rabid fundamentalist preachers, for they will be ministers of an­other sort, utilizing a classroom instead of a pulpit to convey hu­manist values in whatever subject they teach, regardless of the educational level—preschool day care or large state university. The classroom must and will become an arena of conflict be­tween the old and the new—the rotting corpse of Christianity, together with all its adjacent evils and misery, and the new faith of humanism, resplendent in its promise of a world in which the never‑realized Christian ideal of “love thy neighbor” will be fi­nally achieved…. It will undoubtedly be a long, arduous, painful struggle replete with much sorrow and many tears, but humanism will emerge triumphant. It must if the family of humankind is to survive. [1]

Starve a fire of fuel and oxygen, and the fire will go out. Starve cancer cells of what they need to grow, and you will eliminate the cancer.

The State feeds on people. It needs people to function, to survive. The money the State spends to propagandize children comes from the people the State ultimately wants to control. Judges, teachers, politicians, and journalists have mostly been educated by the State. Why are we surprised when they support the State?

Whoever controls the schools rules the world.

There's more in DeYoung's article to respond to, but I'll save that for another time.

  1. “A Religion For A New Age,” The Humanist 43:1 (January-February 1983), 23, 26.[↩]

https://americanvision.org/24897/the-messianic-and-destructive-character-of-american-education/ 

Homeschooling's Greatest Courtroom Victory - By Lee Duigon

Lest we be tempted to take our homeschooling rights for granted, Peter Allison, a homeschooling father in Texas, has been studying a court case that marked the tipping point in a long battle to secure those rights.

The year was 1987; the case was Leeper v. Arlington; the plaintiffs were homeschooling families; the defendant, the public school establishment of Texas, 1,063 individual school districts. The attorney who pled the case for the homeschoolers was Shelby Sharpe, and this is what he had to say about it:

"After the victory that God gave us in that case, the prosecutions [of homeschoolers] stopped in all the other forty-nine states."[i]

"The Leeper case did finally establish the legality of homeschooling," Peter Allison said. "I don't think there'll be any more cases like it."

Rushdoony's Role

Indispensable to the success of the case, Shelby Sharpe recalled, was the performance of R. J. Rushdoony as an expert witness for the plaintiffs. Today, twenty-five years later, we know Dr. Rushdoony as the founder of the Chalcedon Foundation. But he will also be remembered in history as the father of American homeschooling.

"Dr. Rushdoony was a convincing and compelling witness, and played a big role in swinging the case in favor of homeschooling," Allison said. "He was extremely knowledgeable about Texas and its laws-plus he brought to the witness stand his own unique set of gifts and abilities."

Shelby Sharpe put it even more strongly.

"His testimony was way beyond anything I'd hoped for," Sharpe said. "It was one of the few times in my career that I ever saw a witness destroy the attorney who was trying to examine him."[ii]

Rushdoony testified in many such cases all over the country. In the Leeper case, said Allison, he triumphed.

A Surprise Strategy

To establish homeschoolers' rights in Texas, Allison said, Shelby Sharpe took a unique approach. Instead of asking the Texas legislature to pass a new law, Sharpe convinced homeschoolers that the old law, enacted back in 1915, already established their right to educate their own children at home. And instead of trying to defend that right on a case-by-case basis, Sharpe convinced the homeschoolers to attack-demanding a declaratory judgment in their favor against more than a thousand Texas school districts.

"Was homeschooling legal? That was the big question," Allison said. "Shelby Sharpe said that the 1915 law, all the prosecutions notwithstanding, says that homeschooling is legal. He said, ‘The law of 1915 is good. We need a court case, not a new law.'"

Many homeschooling families were being prosecuted in Texas, he said. But this time it would be the public school establishment that would be prosecuted.

Sharpe's argument was that Texas' 1915 compulsory school attendance law specifically exempted private school students from having to go to public school. During the decade of the Nineteen-teens, Sharpe said, sixty percent of school-age children in Texas were being educated at home. "For most Texas families when the law was passed, homeschooling was what you had. So the only meaning the law could have had was that private school meant homeschooling."

Sharpe's surprising strategy, tied to existing law, along with the strong contributions of Rushdoony and some of the other witnesses, led to a victory which continues to bless homeschooling families to this day.

Looking Back, Looking Ahead

The oldest of six children, Peter Allison attended public school in grades 1-3, then went on to a Christian school, and was homeschooled in his teenage years.

"We lived in California at the time, during the mid-1970s," he said. "Homeschooling was considered something that was very far out-the only people who were doing it were hippies. But in Texas at the same time, parents were going to jail for homeschooling their children."

Allison has seven children of his own, all homeschooled (five finished, two to go). He is a pastor at Crown and Covenant Reformed Presbyterian Church, and an electrical engineer, in Conroe, Texas. He also serves as a volunteer in Chalcedon's Extend The Reach program (ETR), representing Chalcedon at homeschooling conferences and other events in his part of Texas.

"After grad school, I always wanted to come back to Texas because of the homeschooling freedom there," he said. "We lived in Pennsylvania for a while, but moved because the homeschooling regulations there were onerous."

Despite the Leeper case, he said, homeschooling still has its opponents. An Internet search along the lines of, say, "teachers against homeschooling," will yield many examples.[iii]

"They won't try, anymore, to outlaw homeschooling," Allison said. "They'll try to kill it by regulation, by increasing parents' expenses."

But homeschooling "is continuing to grow," said Shelby Sharpe, partly because "the public schools are abysmal."

"The challenge now is," Allison said, "that our success could be our downfall-because so many non-religious families are homeschooling now."

Rushdoony's version of Christian homeschooling as a long-term strategy for regenerating America's culture, church, business, and politics continues to inspire homeschooling families and Christian commentators. He had many miles to go, and many battles to fight, before he took the stand in Leeper.

"In the Leeper case," said Allison, "there was one thing Dr. Rushdoony told the court that was really important, and something that should be remember by homeschoolers today. He said that if you don't have the proper motivation in the family, no kind of education will work."

But thanks to the sacrifices made by homeschooling families twenty-five years ago and more, and the leadership of R. J. Rushdoony and many others, Christian homeschooling is still working today.


[i] All quotes by Shelby Sharpe are from his interview by Andrea Schwartz, http://chalcedon.edu/blog/2011/5/9/law-and-liberty-podcast-j-shelby-sharpe-remembers-rush/

[ii] The podcast of the Shelby Sharpe interview provides a link to the courtroom transcript of Dr. Rushdoony's entire testimony.

[iii] A notably obnoxious example of this is provided by "The case against homeschooling" by Jesse Scaccia on the Teacher, Revised website, http://teacherrevised.org/2009/05/30/the-case-against-homeschooling/ . Posted in 2009, the editors of the site recently added a disclaimer: "Please read, but take it with a grain of salt. TeacherRevised supports the right of any parent to homeschool their child." I think we might take that disclaimer as a victory of sorts.

 

Topics: American History, Constitution, The, Education, Family & Marriage, Government, Justice, R. J. Rushdoony, Statism

Lee Duigon

Lee is the author of the Bell Mountain Series of novels and a contributing editor for our Faith for All of Life magazine. Lee provides commentary on cultural trends and relevant issues to Christians, along with providing cogent book and media reviews.

Lee has his own blog at www.leeduigon.com.

→ More by Lee Duigon

https://chalcedon.edu/resources/articles/homeschoolings-greatest-courtroom-victory 

Sunday, November 1, 2020

Vox Popoli: Endgame approaches (Q Test? Stay tuned! - CL)

We're rapidly approaching the mother of all Q-proof tests. If Joe Biden wins, as predicted by all the polls and all the mainstream media, we'll have to conclude that Q was, at best, a morale-boosting LARP. If, on the other hand, Donald Trump wins, even the most dedicated Q skeptics will have to admit that Qanon was more reliable than the entire mainstream media.

And if The Storm begins, everyone will be forced to acknowledge that Q was the real thing from the start.

Item: The National Guard has deployed across 12 states.

Item: "Are you ready to finish what we started? 'Nothing can stop what is coming' is not just a catch-phrase." - Q

Item: A Q post from October 2017 contains some intriguing dates. People assumed at the time that the reference was to 11.4.2017. However, in retrospect, it is clear that the year was never specified and "the next several days" does not refer to the time of the post, but the time of the predicted events.

My fellow Americans, over the course of the next several days you will undoubtedly realize that we are taking back our great country (the land of the free) from the evil tyrants that wish to do us harm and destroy the last remaining refuge of shining light. On POTUS’ order, we have initiated certain fail-safes that shall safeguard the public from the primary fallout which is slated to occur 11.3 upon the arrest announcement of Mr. Podesta (actionable 11.4). Confirmation (to the public) of what is occurring will then be revealed and will not be openly accepted. Public riots are being organized in serious numbers in an effort to prevent the arrest and capture of more senior public officials. On POTUS’ order, a state of temporary military control will be actioned and special ops carried out. False leaks have been made to retain several within the confines of the United States to prevent extradition and special operator necessity. Rest assured, the safety and well-being of every man, woman, and child of this country is being exhausted in full. However, the atmosphere within the country will unfortunately be divided as so many have fallen for the corrupt and evil narrative that has long been broadcast. We will be initiating the Emergency Broadcast System (EMS) during this time in an effort to provide a direct message (avoiding the fake news) to all citizens. Organizations and/or people that wish to do us harm during this time will be met with swift fury – certain laws have been pre-lifted to provide our great military the necessary authority to handle and conduct these operations (at home and abroad).

Item: Boris Johnson announces month-long national lockdown of England.

Item: France is now in a new national lockdown that will last at least a month.

Item: Swiss authorities suggested that another nationwide lockdown was an inevitability.

I strongly suspect that the new European lockdowns, which are being instituted despite the fact that there has not been a significant increase in the number of new cases, the hospitals are not overloaded, the number of deaths is not increasing rapidly, and the infected patients are observably less seriously ill than they were during the previous lockdowns, are related to the coming events rather than to a second wave of the coronavirus.

http://voxday.blogspot.com/2020/11/endgame-approaches.html