Across the land, public pension and medical funds teeter on the
brink of insolvency. You can ignore pending problems until you can’t. For those
who prize clarity and realistic thinking, these impossible to ignore crises
should be welcomed. They focus attention on an inescapable fact: the world
lacks the unencumbered assets and productive capacity to redeem the promises
that have been made against them. Somebody’s going to get stiffed.
With war on everyone’s minds, public pension and medical funds
delineate inevitable battles lines: governments
versus taxpayers, the unproductive versus the productive, the aging versus the
young. Those wars are liable to be far more consequential than the ones
everyone worries about in places like the Middle East and North Korea.
Nothing calls attention to the absurdity riddling the public
pension system quite like the $76,000 monthly pension drawn
by Joseph Robertson, an eye surgeon who retired as president of the Oregon
Health and Science University last fall.
In the good old days, government employment meant low pay, but job
security and a decent pension. Now such sinecures
means wages in excess of those paid in the private sector plus pensions that
are far more munificent…and job security. For a lucky few like Doctor
Robertson, their pensions are a triple 7 jackpot. Oregon calculates pensions
based not just on recipients’ government salaries, but what they receive on any
non-government gigs they had going on the side. Robertson’s pension is based on
his remuneration as university president and what he made operating on
This is what happens when actuarial tables and actual rates of
return are discarded in favor of the political power of public employees and
their unions, promises that can’t be kept, and taxpayers picking up the tab who
have no idea what the final bill will be. Public
pension and medical crises bring into sharp relief the writing on the
wall: Governments Can’t Deliver.
As Charles Hugh Smith recently
noted, public retirement and medical liabilities are increasing so
fast that no amount of tax increases can keep up. Long
before a 100 percent tax rate turns taxpayers into slaves, raising tax rates
becomes counterproductive, yielding less, not more, revenues. One of the nifty
things about the public pension and medical crisis is that it’s local. As such,
it’s offering real world demonstrations that when local jurisdictions raise
rates to fund their pensions, productive people leave.
The poster child is Illinois. The
state on down to its smallest political subdivisions—like the town of Harvey—are
buried beneath underfunded pensions. Illinois’ courts have ruled pensions are
inviolable, which leaves governments facing insolvency with only two options:
raise taxes and cut spending.
Harvey was ordered by a court to fund its firefighters’ pension
fund, which is only 22 percent funded. The town’s property tax rate is six
times the average rate in nearby Indiana, and Harvey is still coming up short.
The state is garnishing its tax revenues, and the town has announced 40 public
safety employees will be laid off. Why would anyone paying taxes in Harvey
stick around for a future of ever-increasing taxes and ever-diminishing public
Many don’t, and Harvey and other localities in Illinois, including
Chicago, are losing people. Out-migration statistics in Illinois, California,
New Jersey, Connecticut, New York, and other net-loser states don’t capture the
full scope of the problem. If one productive person moves out while one
unproductive person moves in and starts living off state largess, there’s been
no net out-migration, but the state suffers a loss (obvious to everyone except
those fools and charlatans who will plump for an open-arms and open-wallet
approach right up until bankruptcy).
Out-migration will get worse for net-loser states as the federal
tax limitations on the deductibility of state and local taxes (SALT) kicks in.
SALT has been capped at $10,000. After that, the wealthy have to pay the full
measure of their high-tax states’ income, property, and sales taxes. The
migration is gathering steam. It already costs twice as much to rent
self-moving truck services from high-tax Los Angeles to low-tax Dallas as vice
versa, and that spread will only widen.
State and local governments, their employees, and those on the
dole can’t stop the productive from voting with their feet. The number who
leave the US, however, is still a trickle. The federal government’s old age and
medical funding problems, orders of magnitude greater than states’ and
municipalities’, are no longer looming; they’ve arrived. The government could
seal the borders to lock in the productive, but it wouldn’t prevent the
slow-motion, but accelerating, catastrophe now underway.
The federal government’s ability to issue virtually unlimited debt
and the Federal Reserve debt monetization machine mask the rot, but only create
problems far larger than the ones they putatively solve. Low
interest rates have destroyed state and local funds’ ability to achieve fairly
safe returns, forcing them out on the risk curve to meet their rate of return
targets, which are way too high. Underfunded as they are now, bear markets in
stocks and bonds would obliterate them.
Encouraged by central bank debt promotion policies, individual,
corporate, local, state, and federal debt has reached new records. While low
interest rates have ameliorated the debt service burden, even they can’t stymie
the toll debt is taking on the economy. Look
no farther than real annual GDP growth, which hasn’t hit 3 percent since Bush
Jr. was in office. Less growth means less tax revenues, which only exacerbates
The older generation is pinning its retirement hopes on a
younger generation confronted with huge debt, perpetually rising taxes, a
shrinking economy, and dwindling opportunity. That’s not like hoping you can
draw to an inside straight, it’s going all in, exchanging your hand for five new
cards, and hoping you draw four aces. Good luck with that.
Oldsters like to complain that the youngsters are too preoccupied
with gadgets and social media. They wish that were
true. The youngsters are already questioning their impending debt servitude. The
more perceptive are homing in on their parents’ generation’s self-granted
benefits and unrivaled profligacy. You don’t have to search too far on the
internet and social media to see the awakening.
Doting parents and grandparents who post their darlings’ every
precocious moment and wouldn’t dream of letting them walking a block to school
by themselves have no compunction about burying them alive under welfare and
warfare state IOUs. In a world riven with conflict, the easiest war to predict
is the intergenerational one.
It’s not strictly accurate to say that the state and local public
pension and medical funds’ crises is the canary in the coal mine. It
is but one in an aviary of canaries. The fund canary is in extremis and may
well be the first to expire; the others will certainly follow. Picture the
horror as the adult canaries and their fledglings wage mortal combat for those
last few molecules of oxygen.