What Great Nation Did Free Trade Ever Build? - By Patrick J. Buchanan
Republican hawks are aflutter today over China's installation of
anti-aircraft missiles on Woody Island in the South China Sea.
But do these
Republicans, good free-traders all, realize their own indispensable role in
converting an indigent China into the mighty and menacing power that seeks to
push us out of Asia?
Last year, China ran up the largest trade surplus in
history, at our expense, $365 billion. We exported $116 billion in goods to
China. China exported $482 billion worth of goods to us.
Using Census Bureau statistics, Terry Jeffrey of
CNSNEWS.com documents how Beijing has, over decades, looted and carted off the
greatest manufacturing base the world had ever seen.
China's trade surplus with us was a paltry $6 million. By 1992, when some of us
were being denounced as "protectionists" for raising the issue, the
U.S. trade deficit with China had crossed the $10 billion mark.
In 2002, it
crossed the $100 billion mark. In 2005, the $200 billion mark. In each of the
last four years, Communist China has run an annual trade surplus at the expense
of the United States in excess of $300 billion.
deficits with China in the Bush-Clinton-Bush-Obama era? $4 trillion. Total U.S.
trade deficit in 2015 — $736 billion, 4 percent of our GDP.
To understand why Detroit looks as it does, while the
desolate Shanghai Richard Nixon visited in '72 is the great and gleaming
metropolis of 2016, look to our trade deficits.
They also help explain America's 2 percent growth, her
deindustrialization, her shrinking share of the world economy, and the
stagnation of U.S. wages as manufacturing jobs are replaced by service jobs.
deficits also explain the rise of Bernie Sanders and Donald Trump.
Yet, with the exception of Trump, none of the GOP
candidates seems willing to debate, defend or denounce the policies that
eviscerated America — and empowered the People's Republic.
Workers, however, know what our politicians refuse
They are being sold out for the benefit of
corporate elites who pay off those politicians with the big cash contributions
that keep the parties flush.
Politicians who play ball with Wall Street and K
Street know they will be taken care of, if they are defeated or when they
retire from public office, so long as they have performed.
Free trade is
not a zero-sum game. The losers are the workers whose jobs, factories and
futures are shipped abroad, and the dead and dying towns left behind when the
manufacturing plants shut down.
on a path of national decline because, while we have been looking out for what
is best for the "global economy," our rivals have been looking out
for what is best for their own nations.
OPEC, which is reeling from the oil price collapse. Russia is colluding with
Saudi Arabia and Iraq to cut production to firm up the market and prevent
prices from falling further.
This is pure
price fixing, but we all understand self-interest.
What might a
U.S. national-interest-based trade policy look like?
largest market on earth, we might impose on foreign producers a cover charge,
an admissions fee, a tariff, to get into our market.
a 20 percent tariff on foreign cars entering the USA. This might raise the cost
of a Lexus or Mercedes produced and assembled abroad from $50,000 to $60,000.
Lexus or Mercedes buys or makes all their parts in the USA and assembles all
their cars here, no tariff. Their cars could still sell for $50,000. This would
be a powerful incentive to shift production here. As an added incentive, all
tariff revenue could be used to reduce or eliminate corporate taxes in the USA.
Civil War and World War I, under Republicans, the U.S. became the world's
greatest industrial power and a wholly self-sufficient nation. How? We taxed
foreign goods entering the United States, but did not tax the profits of U.S.
companies or the incomes of U.S. workers.
The difference between economic patriots and
globalists who inhabit corporate-funded think tanks and public policy
institutes is that the latter think of what is best for their corporate
benefactors and the global economy. The former put America and Americans first.
revere Adam Smith, David Ricardo and Richard Cobden.
But none of
them ever built a great nation. Patriots look to Alexander Hamilton and those
post-Civil War Republicans who built the greatest national industrial
powerhouse the world had ever seen.
great nation did free trade ever build?
As father of
a united Germany, Chancellor Bismarck said, when he decided to build Germany on
the American and not the British model, "I see that those countries which
possess protection are prospering, and that those countries which possess free
trade are decaying."
So it is
true today. Unfortunately, it is America, now wedded to the fatal dogma of free
trade, that is decaying.