An interesting data nugget percolated the other day
about a “sharp worsening” – that is to say, an increase – in
the number of car loan defaults among borrowers under 30 years old. According
to Bloomberg Financial News, the rate for the Millennial demographic was 4.04
percent last quarter vs. 2.36 for the general population, or about twice as
But it’s not just The Youth who are in danger of having their
The overall delinquency rate last quarter was at its
highest level since 2012 – and the total number of car loans (new and used) as
well as leases is up by 5.2 percent.
More people, in other words, are buying cars they can’t
What’s especially interesting is that the increase in
delinquencies isn’t happening in parallel with a recession.
Unemployment is at a 50-year low. So people aren’t defaulting on their car
loans because they lost their jobs.
Their jobs just don’t pay enough to support a car loan.
This shouldn’t surprise anyone who has been following the car
business even casually. It now takes roughly twice as long to pay off a new car
loan as it did in 1970 – about six years vs. three once upon a time. Because
the cost of cars has geometrically outpaced what people are earning.
But not all cars.
In fact, today’s entry-level
cars cost about the same as their analogs of almost 50 years ago.
For example, in 1970, you could by the all-new Chevy Vega (God
help you) for just $2,090 – the equivalent, adjusted for inflation, of just
under $14,000 today. Which could buy you a car like the 2019 Mitsubishi Mirage
I recently reviewed. See here for that.
And the new Mirage does not have a self-melting
engine, as the Vega did (Chevy decided to install the pistons in the aluminum
block without iron cylinder liners) but does have air
conditioning, power windows, locks and even cruise control – things which
only Cadillacs had back in 1970.
The problem is the cost of the average new car.
It approaches $35,000 – which is almost-Cadillac money. Well, it
was – once.
You could buy a ’70 Sedan deVille for $6,118 in 1970 –
equivalent to $40,740 today, or only slightly more money than people are paying
for average cars.
But average people are not earning Cadillac money – while trying
to finance cars that cost Cadillac-equivalent money.
Wherein lies the rub.
If lending standards were stricter, there might not be a
problem. It might even solve some other problems.
One of the reasons – probably – that most people don’t raise a
ruckus about the cost of endlessly proliferating government regulations and
mandates is these costs are made less noticeable to them by extending the time
it takes to pay for them.
Six years now vs. three years then.
If loans were still three or even four years, it would be
impossible for probably half or more of the people currently buying cars to do
This would impose market discipline on
government regs and mandates, motivate average people to take an interest in
cost vs. benefit.
As opposed to believing, like little children, in the Free
They might question, for instance, the value of a car that “saves
gas” by costing them $3,000 (or more) to buy, because it has a direct-injected
rather than merely fuel-injected engine. Or a micro-turbo’d four that costs 10
percent more to buy than a slightly thirstier V6.
Stricter lending standards – loans issued based on people’s
ability to repay them – would also serve the salutary purpose of encouraging
people to live within their means and even possibly below them.
To purchase what they can afford – as opposed to what some
shyster bank will lend them. The bank being shystery for making the loans it
knows borrowers can’t afford and because it knows it can offload the inevitable
delinquencies onto someone else in a kind of musical pickpockets game.
One hand doesn’t wash the other – it filches the cash out of the
wallet of the other.
People might have to drive cars like the $14k Mirage rather than
$38,000 Camrys with 300 horsepower engines that get them to 60 in 5 seconds,
climate control AC, a cheerily glowing LCD touchscreen and such. But
they’d own the thing after making three or four years of
manageable payments – and wouldn’t have to worry about making a payment on the
car – or paying the rent.
They might even have a couple hundred bucks in actual cash money
in their bank accounts, to pay for an unexpected expense –
without having to charge it.
Oh, the humanity.
. . .
Got a question about cars – or anything else? Click on the “ask
Eric” link and send ’em in!
If you like what you’ve found here please consider supporting